A beautiful story of historical fiction. Combining champagne production, war and a love triangle. My only issue was with the reader for the part of Celine. Their performance was not at the same level as the other two readers.

I liked one of the narrators. The other one was kind of robotic in the way she read. It was hard for me because I found myself thinking one of the characters wasn’t very intelligent due to the way the voice came across. This is not accurate so it was distracting for me and took away from my enjoyment of the book a little bit

What a journey! It kept me wanting to continue listening

Loved this book!

Humorous and characters were interesting surprising with twists that just wanted to shake them and tell them to wake up.

I couldn’t stop listening! This book was so well written and the characters were perfectly imperfect.

The narrator for Celine about ruined this book. WHY did the producers let her read Ines as ditsy (when she was just self absorbed) and, worse, use an Asian accent instead of French?! The story was just OK. There were several frustrating and contrived points to the plot (2/3 of my Book Club was frustrated with individual characters and/or the author), but that narrator sure didn't help.

Although I wanted to dislike characters in this story, I couldn’t help but identify with each of them. Great read, tear-jerker - I would read more from this author.

Bittersweet. Frustrating. Intriguing. A wonderfully told story of life, loss, love and redemption.

Great book with a fantastic story line

Enjoyed every minute

Loved this book!!!! Enjoyed the readers’ accents, but their tone put me to sleep a few times

This book captured my attention from the start. Moving story that touched me deeply. I have read several of the author’s books and I am never disappointed.

Great read/listen

Excellent!

Enjoyed this book

Liked the story. I did not like the narrator taking a deeper voice to sound like a man or an old person.