I generally liked the book and I typically relish ‘a new world with a new vocabulary’ but this one left me dismissing much of the vernacular, as it became distracting - too difficult to ‘catch on.’ With that said, I did enjoy the plot, although a bit tough to follow about 2/3’s through. It did leave me wanting to know where the adventure will lead in book 2. I was perfectly fine with the narrator.
I didn't have time to reread the book when I got the sequel, so I decided to listen to the audiobook to quickly refresh my memory. I'm not entirely convinced this version was actually any faster than reading it myself, but at least I was able to listen to it while working instead of spending all my free time reading something I already half remembered. No music, sound effects or ambience here, but I don't require it to rate an audiobook highly. I was Just disappointed, as the authors have a lot of mood music on their website relating to particular characters and scenes, a full playlist for each book.
The audio quality isn't awful for a single narrator, but the accents were incredibly distracting, and sometimes blatantly incorrect. While some things may be personal preference (I'd expected the Liganti accents to be more similar to French, and a Romani accent instead of a Russian one for the Nadezrans, as well as some words and names to be pronounced differently), the narrator has an American accent and uses that for narration and thoughts despite the main character switching between a British and Russian accent for every spoken line. Her Russian accent sounds pretty stereotypical and overdone in a very fake way, too, which is constantly on display for half the cast through the entire story. She also gives random other characters awful American accents, having one high class woman sound like a 90s valley girl from a second-rate teen drama, and often fails to keep the accents steady for emotional scenes or longer dialogue. If I hadn't listened to this on a free trial, I would have demanded a full refund the second Silibat was introduced sounding like a bad Heathers reject. The narrator either accidentally switched to the wrong accent in a few scenes or muddled them enough that it sounded like she did. I admit it's personal preference, but I thought she also spoke too slowly in a number of areas, and both the accents and pronunciation took me out of the story fairly often in places that didn't bother me reading the book normally.
Furthermore, this narrator fails to handle any male dialogue gracefully, as she isn't very good at providing different voices or pitches to the many side characters of the broader cast. Almost every man is all but whispered in an attempt to speak in a lower or huskier voice, which not only caused me to need to rewind it just to hear what was going on frequently, but also makes all men she does this for sound the same, which makes the scenes with groups of characters confusing. Other men are just voiced through her usual narration style, which can make the distinction between dialogue and everything else confusing instead of the previous problem. While the accents grated on my nerves, these issues genuinely made it difficult to hear and understand the book, and in my opinion should have been corrected (either by recording better lines or through leveling the audio) to not have huge drops in volume in the middle of otherwise loud dialogue.
Overall, while I doubt they'll switch to a different voice actor for the sequel, I won't be listing to it aloud if it uses the same woman, and I had a lot of complaints (obviously). The audiobook failed to make certain scenes interesting or emotional, and often chose tones or enunciations that made what had originally seemed clever, intentional repetition just sound annoyingly repetitive, like a mistake. While I didn't think the book itself was perfect originally, I was interested enough to get the sequel and liked much of the worldbuilding, especially the Zorro-esque flair of the Rook. I'll just be sticking to the print version of this series in the future.
By clicking "Notify Me" you consent to receiving electronic marketing communications from Audiobooks.com. You will be able to unsubscribe at any time.
We will send you an email as soon as this title is available.